Top 10 QBs of all time? Let’s debate!

[StarGazer]

Alright, sports fans, time to open up the ultimate can of worms: who makes your top 10 QBs of all time list? NFL, college – doesn’t matter. Just pure greatness. It’s an argument as old as football itself, and honestly, one of the most fun to have.

Personally, I’ve always been fascinated by the mix of talent and strategy that makes a quarterback stand out. For me, Cam Newton has to be in the conversation. I mean, have you seen his 2010 season at Auburn? The man was an absolute beast. That SEC Championship game against South Carolina is etched in my brain. Not just because Newton dominated, but because I had a cheeky little bet on Auburn covering a 5.5-point spread. Newton made sure I walked away $500 richer that night. Moments like that? Priceless.

Now, let’s talk about those GOATs. Whether we’re debating the top 10 NFL QBs of all time, the top 10 college QBs of all time, or even the top 10 greatest QBs of all time, it’s hard not to get into heated discussions. Brady or Montana? Manning or Elway? Heck, throw in Michael Vick for his running game. Speaking of which, who makes your top 10 running QBs of all time? Or better yet, your top 10 worst QBs of all time – just for a laugh.

And for the die-hard fans out there, let’s not stop at QBs. What about the top 10 college football players of all time, regardless of position? Some guys peaked in college and left us with memories that the NFL couldn’t replicate.

So, who’s on your list? Share your picks – and if you’ve got stories tied to your favorites (or a big bet), I’m all ears. Let’s keep it civil, but no promises when someone inevitably leaves Brady or Montana off their list, right?

Looking forward to seeing your rankings, from the top 10 QBs of all time stats to the ones ESPN might argue over!

 

[Scanl@n]

Brady has to top the list, no question. But I’d throw in Peyton Manning and Drew Brees for their insane stats. Cam Newton in college? Totally agree, dude was unreal

 

[NomadicPlay]

Brady, Montana, Manning – they’re the obvious ones. But what about Randall Cunningham? His athleticism was something else.

 

[SandyFoot]

oh jesus not this debate again. everybody knows its brady and then who cares about the rest. the only qb debate i care about is whether mahomes or hurts has more passing yards on sunday. i usually go to sportsbettingag for these props but they don’t have lines up yet - is it worth taking hurts +160 at betonline or should i wait???

 

[SacredDeer2000]

yes, Brady is Brady, no point arguin'. But Mahomes gonna throw more, trust that.

 

[Code413]

Hurts legs take away some pass yards, Mahomes gotta sling it all game.

 

[HorsesDontFly]

But what if Eagles go down early? Hurts might have to throw a ton could be sneaky.

 

[AlexWins]

Brady, Montana, Manning, yeah yeah, we know. But what about college QBs? Tebow, Vince Young, Burrow? That ‘06 Florida team was unreal!